The Supplement Hype: Should Women in Menopause Consider BCAA's?

A Science-Based Guide to Building Muscle During Menopause

You are hearing it everywhere: "Women need to load their body." Your girlfriend who is a trainer says it, your doctor mentions it, and every fitness influencer seems to be preaching it. But what does that actually mean? This is where I find many women are getting stuck. And in order to get on the muscle building train, "experts" in the industry have recommended supplements like branched-chain amino acids (BCAAs) to help your body build muscle. Yet these industry leaders are not as up to date or knowledgeable about the science. If your concern is how to build muscle as quickly as possible, keep reading.

If you're a woman in perimenopause or menopause, this confusion isn't your fault. The fitness and supplement people aren't telling you how your body operates—and what works for a 25-year-old consistent gym goer or athlete may not just be ineffective for you, it could be actively harmful.

The Reality of Your Changing Body

Let's start with the truth: your body has fundamentally changed. During the menopausal transition, declining estrogen levels trigger a cascade of metabolic shifts that affect how you build muscle, process nutrients, and regulate blood sugar. I want to point out here that this metabolic shift is a stress on the body and cells. This is not a stress that you can meditate your way out of.

Research confirms that women can lose 3-8% of their muscle mass per decade starting in their 30s, with this loss accelerating significantly during menopause (plus bone loss).

But here's what most people must start understanding: during this shift you're not just losing muscle—you're also developing what scientists call "anabolic resistance." This means your muscles become less responsive to the typical signals that promote growth, making traditional approaches to muscle building less effective.

Let's add another challenge to this layer: simultaneously, many women in this demographic are experiencing some degree of metabolic dysfunction (cellular stress). If you're struggling with stubborn weight gain, difficulty losing weight, energy fluctuations, or have been told you have the start of some subtle blood sugar issues, your metabolism isn't functioning optimally. Yet the majority of supplement recommendations completely ignore this reality.

What "Load Your Body" Actually Means for Women Over 45

When health professionals tell you to "load your body," they're referring to progressive resistance training—systematically challenging your muscles with increasing weight or resistance over time, starting with where you are at, not the social media influencer who has been doing this for over a decade.

This is scientifically sound advice. Meta-analyses consistently show that resistance training effectively increases muscle mass, lean body mass, and insulin sensitivity (improving your blood glucose problems) in postmenopausal women.

However, there's a critical gap between the recommendation and the execution. Many women receive this advice without:

• Understanding the specific training parameters needed for their age group

• Guidance on progressive overload principles for their tissues and fascia

• Recognition that they may need different training volumes than younger women

• Acknowledgment of their unique metabolic challenges

This leads to well-intentioned but ineffective efforts fuelled by misguided beliefs: using the same 5-pound dumbbells for months, focusing on endless cardio, or turning to supplements as a shortcut.

The BCAA Deception: When "Muscle-Building" Supplements Backfire

Here's where the conversation gets crucial, and where many women are being misled. On the topic of BCAAs—leucine, isoleucine, and valine—are heavily marketed as muscle-building supplements. The marketing isn't entirely wrong: leucine does trigger muscle protein synthesis by activating a key cellular pathway called mTORC1 (a central regulator of cell growth and metabolism).

But there's a massive gap between triggering muscle building and actually achieving it and not tipping the scales of your metabolism. Think of leucine as a foreman shouting "start building!" If you don't have the other eight essential amino acids (the actual building blocks), construction stops.

Research consistently demonstrates that consuming complete protein sources is significantly more effective than isolated BCAAs.

More concerning is what recent research reveals about BCAAs in metabolically compromised individuals—which includes many women experiencing the blood sugar dysregulation common during menopause.

BCAA Supplements: The Hidden Risk for Menopausal Women

Here's the part that should concern every woman considering BCAA supplementation: elevated levels of BCAAs, particularly valine, are strongly associated with insulin resistance and type 2 diabetes risk. A 2022 study published in Nutrition and Diabetes demonstrated that valine supplementation actually worsened glucose tolerance and insulin sensitivity.

The mechanism is both fascinating and alarming. When valine is metabolized, it produces a compound called 3-hydroxyisobutyrate (3-HIB). This metabolite increases glucose uptake into muscle cells in a way that leads to "glucotoxicity"—essentially, the muscle becomes overwhelmed with glucose, leading to cellular stress and impaired insulin signaling, especially for an untrained metabolism.

For a woman already experiencing the metabolic shifts of menopause, supplementing with BCAAs could be like adding fuel to a fire she didn't even know was burning.

The cardiovascular implications are equally concerning. Research published in 2023 linked elevated BCAA concentrations in the blood to an increased risk of atherosclerosis and cardiovascular disease, mediated through inflammation and endothelial dysfunction.

Women are already at an increased risk of cardiovascular disease as estrogen starts disappearing.

Understanding Substrate Utilization: It's Not Just What You Take, It's What Your Body Can Do With It

This brings us to a fundamental principle that the supplement industry and many medical professionals often ignore or just don't fully understand: substrate utilization. Just because you consume a nutrient doesn't mean your body can effectively use it. Your ability to metabolize and utilize any supplement depends entirely on your underlying metabolic health.

If your body is struggling with:

• Insulin resistance

• Chronic inflammation

• Digestive issues

• Impaired cellular energy production

• Diseased states

Then adding more substrates (like BCAAs) won't solve the problem—it will likely exacerbate it. It's literally like pouring more fuel into an already flooded engine.

The Foundation-First Approach: Why Resistance Training is Non-Negotiable

The solution isn't found in a supplement bottle—it's found in systematic, progressive resistance training. The commitment one makes that when done correctly, resistance training doesn't just build muscle; it fundamentally improves the body's ability to process nutrients and regulate metabolism.

As soon as challenge is placed on the body (load), GLUT4 transport proteins in muscle cells move outward towards the surface of the cell. These proteins act like doorways, allowing glucose to enter muscle cells more efficiently. This can happen independently of insulin, making resistance training a primary intervention for metabolic health.

I don't want this to be complicated, rather point out the many different variables that must be considered when recommending an individual to start on a supplement. Without supplementation, resistance training builds the metabolic machinery that allows your body to effectively use the nutrients you consume.

It turns your muscles into "glucose sponges," improving insulin sensitivity, movement quality, and creating a metabolic environment where nutrients and supplements—if needed—can actually be utilized effectively.

The Individualization Imperative

Not all resistance training is created equal, especially for women in your demographic. Postmenopausal women may require higher training volumes to achieve the same muscle-building results as younger women. This doesn't mean you need to spend hours in the gym, but it does mean a commitment to consistency is imperative if you are interested in living vibrantly into this stage of your life.

Key considerations include:

• Progressive overload principles adapted for your starting strength with your unique body history in mind

• Volume (duration/how much weight) and frequency that account for hormonal changes and current health status affecting recovery

• Movement patterns that prepare, are safe and effective for your body

• Recognition that you may need a different approach than what worked in your 20s or 30s, or maybe what you have been doing for the past 20 years.

  
  

Beyond the Fear: Reframing Your Relationship with Strength

Many women in this demographic carry cultural baggage about strength training. You may have grown up during an era when "skinny" was the ideal, when lifting weights was considered masculine, or when the fear of getting "bulky" kept you from even looking the direction of the gym. The era when Muscle & Fitness magazines dawned more muscles than you have ever seen in real life on anyone.

Let me be clear: at your current age and hormonal status, you will not accidentally build excessive muscle mass. If you are just starting now and have fear, remember the anabolic resistance mentioned earlier: it becomes more challenging for muscle building, which also means that the physique changes you fear are unlikely without very specific, intense programming including precisely calibrated nutrition.

What you will build is exactly what you want: lean, metabolically active muscle that improves your strength, energy, bone density, and overall health. You'll build the physical foundation that allows your body to thrive during this transition and beyond.

The Path Forward: Movement Before Molecules

The evidence is clear: for women in perimenopause and menopause, the path to a strong, healthy body begins with resistance training, not supplementation. This "movement before molecules" approach means:

1. Building the metabolic foundation first through systematic resistance training

2. Ensuring adequate complete protein from whole food sources to provide all essential amino acids

3. Considering supplements only as fine-tuning tools once the foundation is solid and preferably under professional guidance

   
   

This isn't about perfection—it's about progression. It's about recognizing that your body deserves an approach that acknowledges its unique needs and challenges, rather than generic solutions designed for different demographics.

Taking the Next Step

If this resonates with you, know that you're not alone in feeling confused by conflicting advice or frustrated by approaches that haven't worked. The transition through menopause is challenging, especially when what you now learn you "need" to do you have never been taught. However, it's also an opportunity to build a stronger, more resilient version of yourself.

The key is starting with the right foundation—one built on science, individualized for your needs, and designed to work with your body's current physiology, not against it.

Your body has changed, but it hasn't given up on you. It's time to give it the support it actually needs.

If you are ready to build a training approach that actually works for your body, join The Estrogen Project for science-backed guidance and start with the Foundation Project designed specifically for women navigating the menopausal transition.

References

1. Bishop, C. A., Machate, T., Henning, T., Henkel, J., Püschel, G., Weber, D., Grune, T., Klaus, S., & Weitkunat, K. (2022). Detrimental effects of branched-chain amino acids in glucose tolerance can be attributed to valine induced glucotoxicity in skeletal muscle. Nutrition & Diabetes, 12(1), 20. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41387-022-00200-8

2. Church, D. D., Hirsch, K. R., Park, S., Kim, I.-Y., Gwin, J. A., Pasiakos, S. M., Wolfe, R. R., & Ferrando, A. A. (2020). Essential Amino Acids and Protein Synthesis: Insights into Maximizing the Muscle and Whole-Body Response to Feeding. Nutrients, 12(12), 3717. PMID: 33276485

3. Holeček, M. (2018). Branched-chain amino acids in health and disease: metabolism, alterations in blood plasma, and as supplements. Nutrition & Metabolism, 15(33). https://doi.org/10.1186/s12986-018-0271-1

4. Schoenfeld, B. J., Contreras, B., Krieger, J., Grgic, J., Delcastillo, K., Belliard, R., & Alto, A. (2019). Resistance Training Volume Enhances Muscle Hypertrophy but Not Strength in Trained Men. Medicine and science in sports and exercise, 51(1), 94–103.

5. Piasecki, M., Stashuk, D., Jaskolska, A., et al. (2018). Age-related neuromuscular changes affecting human vastus lateralis. The Journal of Physiology, 596(6), 1273-1289.

6. Siddik, M. A. B., & Shin, A. C. (2019). Recent Progress on Branched-Chain Amino Acids in Obesity, Diabetes, and Beyond. Endocrinology and Metabolism, 34(3), 234. https://doi.org/10.3803/enm.2019.34.3.234

7. Ramzan, I., Ardavani, A., Vanweert, F., Mellett, A., Atherton, P. J., & Idris, I. (2022). The Association between Circulating Branched Chain Amino Acids and the Temporal Risk of Developing Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus: A Systematic Review & Meta-Analysis. Nutrients, 14(20), 4411. PMID: 36297095

8. Kaspy, M. S., Hannaian, S. J., Bell, Z. W., & Churchward-Venne, T. A. (2024). The effects of branched-chain amino acids on muscle protein synthesis, muscle protein breakdown and associated molecular signalling responses in humans: an update. Nutrition research reviews, 37(2), 273–286. PMID: 37681443